2025 Cleveland Guardians Prospect Rankings & Scouting Reports

Previous Rankings & Reports

OVR=Overall Value Role on 20-80 scouting scale

The table below is a OVR based off of 2022 All-Star fWAR (Fangraphs Wins Above Replacement totals) where the average, median, high and low fWAR for a position player, starting pitcher, and relief pitcher fWAR were taken to determine OVR based on those totals. Prospects OVR were then evaluated based on the figures below.

1. 2B Travis Bazzana - Age: 22 - OVR: 60 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

2. SS Angel Genao - Age: 21 - OVR: 55 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

3. OF Jaison Chourio - Age: 20 - OVR: 50 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2028

4. OF Chase DeLauter - Age: 23 - OVR: 50 - Risk: High - ETA: 2025

5. RHP Braylon Doughty - Age: 19 - OVR: 50 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2029

6. C Cooper Ingle - Age: 23 - OVR: 50 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2026

7. LHP Joey Cantillo - Age: 25 - OVR: 50 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2024

8. 1B Ralphy Velazquez - Age: 20 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2028

9. RHP Andrew Walters - Age: 24 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Low - ETA: 2024

10. 1B CJ Kayfus - Age: 23 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2026

11. RHP Austin Peterson - Age: 25 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2026

12. LHP Parker Messick - Age: 24 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2026

13. 2B Juan Brio - Age: 23 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2024

14. RHP Joey Oakie - Age: 19 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2029

15. RHP Franco Aleman - Age: 24 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

16. INF Welbyn Francisca - Age: 19 - OVR: 45 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

17. RHP Chase Mobley - Age: 19 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2029

18. C Jacob Cozart - Age: 22 - OVR: 45 - Risk: High - ETA: 2028

19. LHP Michael Kennedy - Age: 20 - OVR: 45- Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2028

20. C Kody Huff - Age: 24 - OVR: 45 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

21. INF Luis Merejo Jr. - Age: 19 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2028

22. LHP Matt Wilkinson - Age: 22 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

23. OF George Valera - Age: 24 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2025

24. LHP Erik Sabrowski - Age: 27 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2024

25. OF Johnathan Rodriguez - Age: 25 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2024

26. RHP Nic Enright - Age: 28 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

27. LHP Doug Nikhazy - Age: 25 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

28. LHP Josh Hartle - Age: 22 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2027

29. RHP Cameron Sullivan - Age: 19 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2028

30. OF Petey Halpin - Age: 23 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2026

31. LHP Jackson Humphries - Age: 20 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2028

32. LHP Rafe Schlesinger - Age: 22 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2027

33. RHP Magnus Ellerts - Age: 24 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2026

34. OF Alfonsin Rosario - Age: 21 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2028

35. RHP Dylan DeLucia - Age: 24 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2026

36. OF Nick Mitchell - Age: 21 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2028

37. LHP Ryan Webb - Age: 26 - OVR: 40 - Risk: Moderate - ETA: 2025

38. OF Wuilfredo Antunez - Age: 23 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

39. INF Alex Mooney - Age: 23 - OVR: 40 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

40. OF Kahlil Watson - Age: 22 - OVR: 35+ - Risk: High - ETA: 2027

41. RHP Daniel Espino - Age: 24 - OVR: 35+ - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2026

42. RHP Jacob Zibin - Age: 20 - OVR: 35+ - Risk: Extreme - ETA: 2027

43. INF Dayan Frias - Age: 23 - OVR: 35 - Risk: High - ETA: 2027